Why Barr's Insurance

Protecting the American Dream since 1873

Claim Phone Numbers

     Company

Claim Phone Number

    • Aetna
800-872-3862
    • Allied Insurance
Personal Insurance: 800-282-1466
Commercial Insurance: 866-322-3214
    • American Collectors
800-360-2277
    • American Modern
800-375-2075
    • Amerisafe/American Interstate
800-699-6240
    • AmTrust
877-528-7878
    • ASI – American Strategic
866-274-5677
    • Berkley Mid Atlantic
877-684-5484
    • Brethern Mutual
800-621-4264
    • Chubb (Commercial)
800-252-4670
    • Classic Collectors/Infinity
800-334-1661
    • C.N.A.
877-262-2727
    • Condon & Skelly
800-257-9496
    • Coventry Health Care
800-404-9886
    • Cumberland Insurance
Contact Agent
    • Eastern Alliance
800-336-3658
    • Farmers Insurance Group
800-435-7764
    • Farmers Mutual
800-545-7806
    • Foremost
800-527-3907
    • Frederick Mutual
866-212-5243
    • Hagerty (Encompass)
877-922-0405
    • Harleysville
800-892-8877
    • The Hartford
800-243-5860
    • Highmark
800-235-5017
    • JC Taylor
800-272-6764
    • Lackawanna
888-280-5225
    • Millers Capital
800-745-4555
    • Millville Mutual
800-262-8495
    • Mutual Benefit Group
800-290-6361
    • Ohio Casualty
866-255-5530
    • Penn National Insurance
800-766-2245
    • Progressive
800-274-4499
    • Rockwood Casualty
800-837-9062
    • Safeco
800-332-3226
    • Selective Flood
877-348-0552
    • Selective Insurance
866-455-9969
    • Travelers Indemnity
800-252-4633
    • UPMC Health Plan
888-876-2756
    • Utica National
Workers Comp: 800-516-1420
All Others: 888-538-2018
    • Westfield Insurance
866-937-2663
    • Zurich
800-987-3373

Our Insurance Partners

Pennsylvania Pittsburgh Insurance
"We are excited to launch our new responsive website that provides a fresh platform."
- Joe Pastor, President, Barr's Insurance
PGlmcmFtZSBoZWlnaHQ9IjM0OCIgYWxsb3dUcmFuc3BhcmVuY3k9InRydWUiIGZyYW1lYm9yZGVyPSIwIiBzY3JvbGxpbmc9Im5vIiBzdHlsZT0id2lkdGg6MjUwO2JvcmRlcjpub25lIiAgc3JjPSJodHRwczovL3dlYnN1bHRzLnd1Zm9vLmNvbS9lbWJlZC96MWVtaW5xNTBtZGdnY2QvIj48YSBocmVmPSJodHRwczovL3dlYnN1bHRzLnd1Zm9vLmNvbS9mb3Jtcy96MWVtaW5xNTBtZGdnY2QvIj5GaWxsIG91dCBteSBXdWZvbyBmb3JtITwvYT48L2lmcmFtZT4=